Hepatitis C incidence is increasing among gay and
bisexual men living with HIV in San Diego, according to the largest analysis of
its kind done in the United States. Study results were presented this week at
the 2017 AASLD Liver Meeting in Washington, DC.
Not surprisingly, the small number of
men who reported injecting drug use had a higher likelihood of being newly
infected with hepatitis C virus (HCV), but so did the much larger proportion who
reported non-injection methamphetamine use.
Starting in the early 2000s
researchers in the UK and elsewhere in Europe began to report clusters of
apparently sexually transmitted acute HCV infection among HIV-positive men who
have sex with men (MSM). Similar outbreaks have since been seen in Australia
and the US.
Several risk factors have been implicated
in sexual transmission of HCV among men who say they do not inject drugs,
including condomless anal sex, fisting, use of sex toys, other sexually
transmitted infections and non-injection drug use. However, these
factors have not been consistent across studies. Experts have traditionally
assumed that HCV is transmitted through sexual activity that involves blood,
but the virus has also been detected in semen, rectal secretions and faeces.
To date, acute HCV has mostly been
seen among HIV-positive MSM. But a small number of cases have been reported
among HIV-negative gay men as well – including participants
in the Kaiser Permanente San Francisco pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) programme and the UK PROUD and French Ipergay PrEP studies.
After seeing rising HCV rates among HIV-positive gay
men attending the UCSD
Owen Clinic, San Diego's largest HIV clinic,
Antoine Chaillon of the University of California at San Diego and colleagues
did a retrospective pooled analysis of HCV incidence among HIV-positive MSM
attending the Owen Clinic and the San Diego Veterans Affairs (VA) Hospital between
2000 and 2015. Together these centres see about a third of the estimated 3400
HIV-positive MSM in the city.
Incident HCV infection was defined as a newly positive
HCV antibody or HCV RNA test during follow-up among people who had previously
tested negative for hepatitis C. The researchers classified risk based on ever
reporting a history of injecting drug use (self-reported) or methamphetamine
use (self-reported at the Owen Clinic, based on urine tests at the VA).
This analysis included 2768 MSM – 2396 at the Owen
Clinic and 373 at the VA – who were initially HCV negative and had at least one
subsequent test during a median of about 4 years of follow-up. About two-thirds
were white, 12% were black and 24% were of Latino/Hispanic ethnicity. VA
patients were a bit older (42 vs 38 years) and more likely to be African
American than Owen Clinic clients.
About 40% said they had no history of drug injection
or meth use, 1% (just 22 individuals) reported only injecting drug use, 51%
used meth only and 7% both injected and used meth. VA patients were more likely
than Owen Clinic clients to say they did not inject drugs or use meth (58 vs
40%), had a history of injecting only (13 vs 0.4%) or both injected and used
meth (14 vs 7%), but they were much less likely to have used meth only (16 vs
A total of 172 HCV seroconversions occurred during a
cumulative 14,444 person-years of follow-up, for an incidence rate of 1.19 per
100 person-years (PY). Of the total, 149 infections occurred among Owen Clinic
clients and 23 among VA patients. There were no notable differences in
infection rates according to age or race/ethnicity.
This primary (first HCV infection) incidence rate was
similar to rates for HIV-positive MSM previously reported in Boston and the US
national HOPS cohort (1.6 and 1.23 per 100 PY, respectively), but higher than
rates in Seattle or the nationwide MACS cohort (0.89 and 0.34 per 100 PY).
HCV incidence among HIV-positive gay and bi men in San
Diego quadrupled over time, with a particularly steep rise among men who used
meth but did not inject drugs:
- 0.36 per 100 PY during 2000-2003
- 1.10 per 100 PY during 2004-2007
- 1.14 per 100 PY during 2008-2011
- 1.52 per 100 PY during 2012-2015.
Looking at risk factors, HCV incidence rates were 0.49
per 100 PY among people who never injected drugs or used meth, 1.49 among those
who used meth only, 2.2 among those who both injected and used meth and 2.59
among those who reported injecting drug use only. That is, incidence was three
times higher among men who reported only meth use, but not injecting drug use,
compared to those with no history of either. Incidence was about 5 times higher
among men who reported only injecting drug use and more than 4 times higher
among men who reported both drug injection and meth use, compared to those who
said they did neither.
The researchers also did an analysis of HCV
reinfection, which only included men at the Owen Clinic who had been cured with
treatment between 2006 and 2014 (implying most of them received
Among the 43 individuals followed, there were three
reinfections, which works out to 2.89 per 100 PY. Two reinfections occurred
about 2.5 years and one occurred about 6 years after being cured. Chaillon
noted that this is lower than reinfection rates seen in some European studies:
15.2 per 100 PY in Amsterdam, 9.6 in London and 7.3 in
the European NEAT cohort. One of his colleagues said that all
three reinfected men were retreated and cured a second time.
"These congruent results from the two largest HIV
clinics in San Diego reinforce our findings that HCV incidence is high and
increasing among HIV-positive MSM in San Diego," similar to what has been
observed in major European cities, the researchers concluded.
They emphasised the need for guidelines on regular HCV
testing for gay and bi men, rapid diagnosis and treatment to prevent
transmission, strategies to prevent reinfection and interventions around
substance use and chemsex.
Asked about testing HIV-negative men seeking PrEP for HCV, Chaillon said they had not yet done so
but this was worth pursuing.