People with viral hepatitis who smoked were three times more likely
to die after being diagnosed with liver cancer (hepatocellular
carcinoma, HCC), according to a study of Swiss patients published in Liver International.
non-smokers lived for a median of 3.2 years after diagnosis, smokers
died after a median of 18 months. Smoking had a similar impact on
survival in those who did not receive curative treatment in the form of
liver resection (surgery), liver transplantation or ablation (use of
heat to destroy tumours in the liver).
Smoking has been found to increase the risk of developing liver
cancer in some, but not all studies, and to increase the risk of liver
cancer in some studies of people with viral hepatitis.
To look at the effect of continuing to smoke after a diagnosis of
primary liver cancer (HCC) Swiss researchers analysed survival in 238
people with at least 12 months of follow-up after diagnosis of HCC.
Sixty-four reported smoking at the time of inclusion in the cohort
study. Smokers were followed for a median of 489 days and non-smokers
for 1170 (p = 0.002), the difference reflecting the poorer survival in
HCC developed at a younger age in smokers (59 vs 66 years, p < 0.001).
There was no significant difference between smokers and non-smokers
in the stage of liver cancer whether measured by Child-Pugh grade or
BCLC (Barcelona Clinic Liver Cancer) system, nor in any markers of liver damage with the exception of platelet
counts and INR (international normalised ratio) scores. Smokers showed some evidence of greater liver
injury. They had lower platelet counts and slightly higher INR scores.
(Smokers usually have higher platelet counts than non-smokers.)
There was no difference between smokers and non-smokers in the type of treatment they received.
HCC attributable to viral hepatitis (B or C) or alcohol was more common in smokers.
A multivariate analysis which controlled for other risk factors
showed that smoking increased the risk of death in people with viral
hepatitis diagnosed with HCC (HR 2.41, 95% CI 1.28-4.41, p = 0.007) but
not in people with liver cancer attributable to other causes. A more
advanced stage of HCC at diagnosis also increased the risk of death (HR
2.73, 95% CI 1.93-3.85, p < 0.001).
Smoking is known to increase liver fibrosis in people with hepatitis C
and might also directly influence HCC progression after diagnosis.
Poorer fitness or less compliance with medical treatment or advice might
also affect survival, the investigators suggest. They say that it is
not possible to tell from their cohort whether the effect of smoking was
a consequence of smoking intensity – how many cigarettes a day – or
duration (persistence in smoking after diagnosis).
“Based on these findings, smoking cessation should be considered for
incorporation into the disease management for patients with HBV or HCV
[with HCC],” the authors conclude. They point out that around 80% of HCC
cases worldwide are probably attributable to viral hepatitis.